For the most part the Cwtch risk model for groups is split into two distinct profiles:
- Groups made up of mutually trusted participants where peers are assumed honest.
- Groups consisting of strangers where peers are assumed to be potentially malicious.
Most of the mitigations described in this section relate to the latter case, but naturally also impact the former. Even if assumed honest peers later turn malicious there are mechanisms that can detect such malice and prevent it from happening in the future.
In the ideal case we would use a protocol like OTR, the limitations preventing us from doing so right now are:
- Offline messages are not guaranteed to reach all peers, and as such any metadata relating to key material might get lost. We need a key derivation process which is robust to missing messages or incomplete broadcast.
Status: Partially Mitigated (but impossible to mitigate fully)
Whether dealing with trusted smaller groups or partially-public larger groups there is always the possibility that a malicious actor will leak group messages.
We plan to make it easy for peers to fork groups to mitigate the same key being used to encrypt lots of sensitive information and provide some level of forward secrecy for past group conversations.
Status: Partially Mitigated
Group members, who have access to the key material of the group, can conspire with a server or other group members to break transcript consistency.
While we cannot directly prevent censorship given this kind of active collusion, we have a number of mechanisms in place that should reveal the presence of censorship to honest members of the group.
- Because each message is signed by the peers public key, it should not be possible (within the cryptographic assumptions of the underlying cryptography) for one group member to imitate another.
- Each message contains a unique identifier derived from the contents and the previous message hash - making it impossible for collaborators to include messages from non-colluding members without revealing an implicit message chain (which if they were attempting to censor other messages would reveal such censorship)
Finally: We are actively working on adding non-repudiation to Cwtch servers such that they themselves are restricted in what they can censor efficiently.